Market review and bond markets

Equity markets fell marginally in September, with expectations for further interest rate rises a driver behind the weakness in bond markets. The Federal Open Market Committee unanimously raised US interest rates by 25 basis points. It also published economic projections that pointed to a tougher stance on inflation, with Federal Reserve Chair Kevin Warsh stressing the need to remove some of the support low interest rates give the economy. The European Central Bank, the Bank of Japan, Norges Bank, and the Reserve Bank of Australia also raised rates.

US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent defended his intervention in currency and US government bond markets, telling investors: “I have asymmetric information. I am the house now. You can bet against me if you want.” His intervention has had little effect, and arguably the opposite, with US government bond yields continuing to rise despite increasingly buying back its own bonds. Against that background, the sector fell 3.1%, dragged down by the weak performance of US financials. The Trust’s net asset value1  fell 2.2% during the month, outperforming its benchmark, the MSCI All Country World Financials Index, which fell 3.1%. 


European financials conference

The conference season provided an excellent opportunity to catch up with the management teams of many European financial companies across the sector. We received a reassuring update on the operating outlook for European banks, with management teams pointing to continued loan growth, resilient net interest margins2 and stable asset quality3. Banks in Southern Europe are still seeing a greater benefit from the recent interest rate increases feeding through to revenue and therefore earnings. 

We have slightly changed our mix of European banks by increasing our exposure to ING Groep (ING), the Netherlands' largest bank. ING is more sensitive to longer-term interest rates, whereas the periphery is more sensitive to short-term rates. Not unlike the UK banks, ING is benefiting from its 'replicating portfolio', where redeeming securities are reinvested into new government bonds at longer maturities, providing a medium-term tailwind for earnings. We also expect recent moves higher in bond yields to be positive for earnings, although we expect the benefit will feed through more slowly than for banks in Southern Europe, where we retain holdings across Italy, Spain and Greece.


US financials

While European financials rose over the month, US financials were particularly weak, led by US banks. As we highlighted in a previous commentary, Q2 earnings for US banks were much better than expected, due largely to strong trading revenues from their investment banking operations. However, in an update at another conference during the month, Bank of America expects to see weaker trading revenues in its investment bank for Q3, which prompted the sector to sell off. This was despite other banks, such as JP Morgan and Citigroup, forecasting continued growth and the industry seeing a pick-up in initial public offering (IPO) activity, which has been a weak spot in recent years.

The release of the Muse personal agent by Meta Platforms (owner of Facebook) in September also led to a selloff similar to, but smaller than, the one seen in February, when a dystopian blog about the disruption from artificial intelligence (AI) triggered a sharp fall in the share prices of companies seen as vulnerable. Unsurprisingly, many of these had seen a full or partial recovery in the intervening months. To paraphrase Donald Rumsfeld, former US Secretary of State for Defence, the known unknown is the willingness of consumers to use such agents. Direct-to-consumer models that offer lower-cost services have struggled to get traction in some markets, while the risks of giving data to a third party and the potential regulatory response lead to divergent views. For now, compared to the benchmark, we remain underweight the companies we see most at risk.


Asia-Pacific

Along with European banks, we remain overweight South Korean and Japanese banks, the latter continuing to perform extremely well. Interest rate expectations still assume higher policy rates by the end of 2027, led by both countries. Japanese banks are very sensitive to rising interest rates and, with loan growth picking up and the AI capital expenditure cycle little affected by higher rates, we see the backdrop for banks as supportive. South Korean banks combine margin expansion with resilient asset quality, low valuations and attractive total returns, supported by the Value-Up Program encouraging higher shareholder returns.

We also hold positions in Taiwan, where the technology boom is supporting growth and banks earn more from their currency trading with the US dollar as the interest rate differential widens, and in Singapore, where banks gain from both higher interest rates and growth in wealth management revenues. India is more complicated given the impact of higher oil prices and we remain underweight. That said, a short interest rate hiking cycle by the Reserve Bank of India and an easing in energy market dislocation would present opportunities in a market where valuations have lowered and the longer-term growth outlook is appealing. 


Outlook

The sector has lagged wider equity markets over the past two months and year to date. While it is not alone in doing so, with the technology sector significantly outperforming over this period, the fundamentals are solid so we remain very positive. Consequently, profit forecasts are still positive. If AI continues to power growth, we see the sector remaining a beneficiary of that, with a more attractive interest rate background allowing margins and loan growth to generate higher revenues. 

Furthermore, higher equity markets support healthy investment banking revenues and increased fees from wealth management and asset management businesses. Finally, strong corporate cashflows and a resilient consumer are not leading to any pick-up in bad debts, while what is so far a benign hurricane season which we think points to another year of strong profits for the insurance sector. 


[1] The total value of all the investments and cash held less any borrowings divided by the number of shares.
[2] The gap between what banks earn on loans and pay on deposits
[3] How likely loans are to be repaid